The rate without materials is the most searched figure in this trade and at the same time the least informative. It describes one item among many, and it is the others that decide what you end up paying.
Both are legitimate and each suits something different. The trouble starts when the wrong one is chosen for the job, or when the two are mixed without it being clear what falls where.
The choice between a masonry partition block and drywall is usually made on price and speed. The consequences show up elsewhere: in what the wall will hold, in how well you hear the neighbour and in what happens when you want to change the layout.
Most enquiries say "I need the flat plastered". No quote can be built from that, so what comes back is either a guess or questions that delay the job by days. A few extra sentences fix it.
Renovations do not go wrong because somebody plastered badly. They go wrong because something was done earlier than it should have been, or later than it could have been. This article sets out the sequence and, for each stage, what is hard to change afterwards.